Enofe v Hernandez
Tenant wins · Brampton · 2025-07-21
- Adjudicator
- Amanda Kovats
- Dispute
- Maintenance, Renovation, Major Repairs
- Notice
- Major repairs or renovations (N13)
- Landlord
- A.E.
- Tenant
- C.H.
What happened
The Landlord requested a review of a previous order that dismissed an application to terminate the tenancy for major repairs (N13). The original application was dismissed because the Member was not satisfied the Landlord would actually perform the work and found the Landlord was in serious breach of maintenance responsibilities. The Landlord argued that the previous order relied on irrelevant evidence of past tenant complaints and misapplied the law. The Board conducted a preliminary review and found no serious error, confirming the dismissal of the eviction application.
The ruling
The Landlord's request for review is denied. The original order dated June 24, 2025, which dismissed the Landlord's application to evict the Tenant for renovations, remains in effect. The Board confirmed that the Landlord's serious breach of maintenance obligations and the lack of evidence regarding valid building permits were sufficient grounds for dismissal.