Boyle v Shen

Landlord wins · Kingston · 2025-09-12

Adjudicator

Margo den Haan

Dispute

Harassment, Illegal Entry, Maintenance, Tenant Rights

Landlord

R.S.

Tenant

D.B.

Landlord rep

Marc-Roger Gagne

Tenant rep

Kurtis Scouten

What happened

The Tenant filed T1 and T2 applications alleging illegal rent collection, illegal entry, harassment, substantial interference with enjoyment, and withholding of vital services. The T1 application regarding illegal rent was withdrawn during the hearing. The T2 application was dismissed as the Tenant failed to provide sufficient evidence to support the claims of illegal entry during renovations and damage to property from drywall dust.

The ruling

The Tenant's T1 application was withdrawn. The Tenant's T2 application was dismissed in its entirety. The Landlord was found to have acted within legal rights regarding unit entry and renovations. Allegations of property damage and interference were not supported by sufficient evidence.